MAKE AHEAD HOLIDAY/EVENT CAKES
Our Christmas dessert had always been home-made cookies and parfaits of sherbet, with whipped cream and my Mother’s home frozen blueberries, which looked and tasted fresh. I loved the light and refreshing finish, but times change, families merge and new traditions form. The cookies remain, but the parfaits are gone, replaced by a selection of cakes.
However, cakes and the time they take to make, create a scheduling problem in the hectic days before a holiday, or any event for that matter. Obviously, they had to be made ahead and freezing seemed the best option, but frosted cakes were a new field. Sara Lee did it but could I, at home? Moreover, desserts for winter holidays require more elegance than other occasions, the recipes more sophisticated, dependent on cooking techniques. They are visually decorative and though perhaps loaded with calories, lighter in texture than things that can be picked up by hand or served in slivers.
Furthermore, when the main entrée is eaten, I want nothing more than to clear the table, and set out the desserts without any further prep in the kitchen. I may have to face the dishes later, but from that point on, my main duties are over and I want to enjoy the rest of the time with my guests. For me, it’s important to have most of the cooking done before the day.
I decided to jump right in and I’m so glad I did because I found freezing even the most elegant desserts works. Now, I make them as I find time and they’re ready ten days to a week ahead, some even more. I have a large freezer and I’m able to freeze finished baked goods, but for those with less room, cake layers can be stacked and stored while the icings can be kept in the refrigerator. Actually, cakes will keep, chilled, for several days, even in a cold garage.
A bonus is that most of these recipes can serve for other holidays/events. Of course the Pistachio Marble Cake is a fit for Saint Patrick’s Day, and with coconut sprinkled on top, for Easter. The Red Velvet Cake, with white icing and coconut can also do for Easter, or with blue icing outside, for 4th of July. Substitute a lighter quick bread mix, one with a fruit, for the pumpkin, add a drizzle of white icing, and the Christmas Bread becomes a Hot Cross Loaf for Easter. As for the Yule Log, follow the directions for alternate cake mixes, form it into a single log and change the decorations for the season or occasion and it’s ready for any event. The Opera Cake, Pecan Bars and the Black Forrest Brownies are always ready to go.
The following recipes provide this freedom, and serve as examples of how similar ones can be treated the same way. I’ve included a list of tips on storing, handling and repurposing leftovers. While on the subject of make-ahead desserts for the holidays, be sure to check out the posting on Cranberry Desserts published on this site Nov. 29, 2018. I especially love the Orange, Cranberry, Walnut Ice Cream, based on commercial ice cream, so it’s quite easy, and keeps for weeks.
RECPIES
CHRISTMAS BREAD: People who normally hate fruitcake, like this, especially with a cup of coffee or tea, because it has a lighter texture—half way between bread and cake
This is kinda cheating because it’s based on two boxed Quick Bread mixes. I like Cranberry and Pumpkin, but have used Date and Nut as well, especially for other occasions. In fact, I might add them if I were to make more than 2 loaves.
If the mixes have different add-in requirement amounts, so I mix them in separate bowls and combine the batters. In each mix I replace half the liquid with red wine, which acts as a preservative.
Before adding that I toss a total of ½ cup chopped nuts and ¾ cups mixed chopped, dried fruits in the dry flour. This prevents clumping in the batter.
I decorate the tops with whole nuts, candied cherries and colored sugar, then bake as directed in two loaf pans-one per box of mix used. When the loaves are cool, I sprinkle the tops with about 2 Tbs. of whiskey, cover them in plastic wrap These should be made in October, but they can be baked as little as 2 weeks before serving . The alcohol doesn’t taste, but preserves and deepens flavor. They are fine to serve children. In fact they make great breakfast bread.
YULE LOG—Serves 16-18
Using boxed Gingerbread mix, I replace half the water with applesauce, add ¼ cup oil and use 2 eggs. Beat only until well incorporated – about 2 min.
Grease the bottom only of a 19 x 11 inch jelly roll pan. Line it with parchment paper and grease the paper.
Preheat the oven to 350 deg., and bake on the middle rack for 16 to 18 min. until it springs back when poked lightly with a finger.
Remove from the oven and sprinkle liberally with powdered sugar. Cover with a tea towel, and using a board as a brace invert the cake. Peel off the parchment and roll the long side of the cake in the towel. Resting the edge on the bottom let the cake cool completely.
Meanwhile, beat 8 oz. cream cheese with 8 oz. Cool Whip until smooth adding 2 tsp. maple flavoring -or to taste, and 1/3 cup chopped, toasted walnuts or pecans.
Carefully unroll the cake and fill with the cheese mixture. Re-roll. Trim ends evenly.
Cut a piece about 3 inches long from one end on an angle and position it along the “trunk” to form a branch. Secure it with a bit of frosting.
Frost the cake and add any decorations. Freeze until ready to serve. Allow to thaw 30 to 45 min.
General Recipe for Roulade Cake: Adapted from The Cake Doctor by Ann Bryn. This General Recipe for Roulade Cake allows many options for flavor changes
1 box plain cake mix
1 cup buttermilk
½ cup vegetable, seed or nut oil
4 eggs
Confectioners’ sugar for dusting
Parchment paper
Butter for preparing pan
Make the cake: Butter the bottom only of a 16 ½ X 11 ½ X 1 inch jelly roll pan. Line it with the parchment, leaving a couple inches overlap on the ends, and butter the paper. Put the cake ingredients in a bowl and beat, scraping the sides, until batter is thick and combined about 3 min. Pour into the prepared pan, smoothing it out with a spatula. Bake on the center rack of a preheated 350 deg. oven for 15-17 min. until it springs back when pressed with a finger. Liberally dust a clean kitchen towel and starting with the long side, carefully roll the cake away from you in the towel. Place seam side down on a flat surface to cool for about 20 min. Follow directions above for assembly.
NOTE: If the cake seems split in places, and it will as it’s rolled, the frosting will cover them. Garnish with sprinkled cinnamon or nuts.
MODIFIED OPERA CAKE Serves 10-12
(3) 9 inch round cake pans—available as a 3-pack in a dollar store
Parchment paper or waxed paper
1 box yellow cake mix and ingredients listed on package*
8 oz. container whipped topping
8 oz. cream cheese
1 tsp. almond extract
1 can dark chocolate frosting
Toasted slivered almonds—optional for garnish
Cut parchment rounds to fit cake pans. Grease pan bottoms and paper rounds. Mix batter according to package directions and place 1/3 in each pan. Bake at package stated temperature for 1/3 the time recommended, usually about 15-18 min. or until top springs back when lightly pressed. Cool then invert onto plates and peel off paper. If necessary, slice tops to level them.
Beat cheese, topping and extract together until smooth. Plate one cake layer and cover with a thin layer of frosting, spread ½ the cheese mixture on top and repeat with a second layer. Top with the 3rd layer even side up making sure it’s level. Remove excess filling from sides with a knife if needed.
Microwave remaining frosting 20-30 sec. until easily pourable but not too runny and using a spoon as a guide if necessary, pour evenly over the top of the cake to create a smooth glazed effect . It’s O.K. if some runs decoratively down the sides. Decorate with toasted slivers of almonds or a sprig of holly in the center.
Re-freeze as at first for later use. Serve leftovers in slices in a circular pattern on a plate.
* For a more authentic Opera Cake
3 eggs separated
6 Tbs. sugar
Dash salt
¾ cup sifted cake flour
½ tsp. vanilla
3 Tbs. sugar
Beat yolks, sugar and salt until light and fluffy, about 5 min. Fold in flour. Beat whites until soft peaks form and then beat, adding sugar, until peaks are stiff. Fold a glob of whites into yolk mixture, then fold in the rest. Pour into pans and bake at 325 deg. for 15 min. Ice and store as for box mix.
Red Velvet Christmas Cake: Serves 12
A stunning cake can be made with the above technique baking the batter in 3 pans
1 box red velvet cake mix, baked according to directions in 3, 9 inch round pans. You will have to adjust time, but see the Opera Cake above
Frosting
8 oz. cream cheese
8 oz. container of Cool Whip
Confectioners’ sugar to taste-optional
1 tsp. or to taste peppermint or other flavoring
Few drops green food coloring—optional
Beat the above ingredients together until smooth and creamy, adding sugar if desired to taste, flavoring and enough coloring to turn the mixture a light green. Frost the layers and then the outside of the cake. Decorate with sprigs of holly or crushed candy canes.
PISTACHIO MARBLE CAKE
Requirements: 1 mixing bowl; 2 layer cake pans or 1 tube pan
1 box marble cake mix WITHOUT pudding included. White or yellow will do if you can’t find marble*. The important thing is no pudding in the mix.
(1) 4 serving size box pistachio instant pudding and pie filling mix.
1 1/3 cup water
3 eggs
1/3 cup of oil
1 can dark chocolate creamy or whipped frosting mix OR make pistachio frosting if you want the cake to have a soft green appearance (Nice for Christmas and Easter)-see directions below
¾ cup coarsely chopped pistachio nuts (optional)
Cooking spray
3 Tbs. unsweetened cocoa powder*
This can be made in 2 layer pans but appears more attractive when cut if made in a tube or bunt pan. Prepare pan(s) by spraying liberally with cooking spray. Preheat oven to 350 degrees.
Beat the eggs, water, pudding mix and oil into the batter until it is smooth. See cake mix directions. Using a spoon, blend in ½ cup nuts. Pour 2/3 of the batter into the prepared pan(s) if using a marble mix directions will say to add contents of the enclosed envelope to the remaining 1/3 batter in the bowl. * If not, add the cocoa powder and blend well. The cake box directions will now tell you to pour the chocolate batter over that in the pan(s) and using a table knife, blade down, in a cutting motion, gently swirl the top layer into the one below, creating a marble effect. If using a tube pan, go down to reach the bottom, but don’t overdo.
Bake the cake for the times dictated on the box for your choice of pan. Cool as directed and frost with the chocolate frosting. Use the rest of the nuts as garnish. If using a pistachio frosting there is the option of garnishing with chocolate curls or chips.
Pistachio Frosting
Makes enough to fill and frost 2 layers
I don’t like very sugary frostings, nor do I need one high in calories and fat. So I’m offering 2 recipes here. The first is the classic Kraft recipe for pudding icing and the second is my own creation. There is a third choice which uses only whipped topping, but I find that is so light that it soaks into the cake in a day and can’t be made in advance.
1) Kraft Pudding Icing
Makes about 2 ½ cups
(1)4 oz. pkg. = ½ of 8 oz. pkg. cream cheese, softened
1 stick= ½ cup unsalted butter, softened
1 ½ cups powdered sugar
1 pkg. (3.4 oz.) Pistachio flavor instant pudding and pie filling
Using an electric mixer beat together cream cheese and butter until well combined. Add pudding and beat on high speed until light and fluffy and pale in color, approximately 5 min. Gradually add powdered sugar and beat until fully incorporated and fluffy.
My Pudding Icing
Makes about 4 cups
(1) 8 oz. pkg. cream cheese
(1) 8oz. tub whipped topping
(1) 4 serving box of pistachio instant pudding and pie mix
Beat all 3 ingredients together until completely blended, smooth and spreadable.
Pecan Bars: Yield 24 squares
1 box pecan cake mix
1/3 cup cooking oil
2 large eggs
8 oz. cream cheese
1/3 cup sugar
2 tsp. Maple flavoring
1-2 Tbs. milk
Beat the cake mix with the oil and 1 egg until crumbly-about 1 ½ -2 min. Reserve 1 cup; press the rest onto the bottom only of a 9 x 13 inch ungreased baking pan. Bake on middle rack of a preheated 350 deg. oven 13-15 min. until golden. Leave oven on. In beating bowel, with the same beaters, combine cheese, sugar flavoring and 1 Tbs. milk. Beat until creamy adding other Tbs. milk as needed. Top with reserved cup of crumbs. Bake about 15 min. until top is golden. Cool and cut into squares.
Black Forrest Brownie Swirl: Yield 24 brownies
1 box brownie mix (24 oz.)
1 can cherry pie filling
1/4 cup oil
3 eggs
¼ cup sugar
8 oz. cream cheese
1 tsp. vanilla
Candied cherries
Prepare brownie mix using oil and 2 eggs and ½ cup pie filling until well mixed. Stir in and lightly beat another ½ cup pie filling, leaving some cherry chunks.
Beat cheese, 1 egg, sugar and vanilla until smooth. Pour over brownie mix and cut through with a knife several times to give a marble effect. Arrange candied cherries over the top. Bake at 350 deg. 35-30min. until cheese is set and beginning to tan. Cool in pan and cut.
Tips for serving, storing and leftovers:
1) Protecting an iced or garnished cake’s appearance during packaging is done with marshmallow tipped toothpicks placed in strategic spots around the cake, being careful not to let the marshmallow touch the frosting. If the cake is to be frozen for more than five days to a week, once the icing’s frozen solid, you may want to remove the toothpicks and marshmallows and wrap the plastic directly on the surface. This eliminates the air spaces, which allow ice crystals to form that can taint taste and, in thawing, water down the icing. In any case, remove the wrapping as soon as the cake’s out of the freezer and let it thaw naturally, in the air. Don’t worry about the puncture marks. It’s simple to cover them with a knife tip before serving.
2) Incidentally, leftovers re-freeze well, and can be sliced and served fanned on a plate for another occasion, or just cut a slice off for a snack. Discovering how to use cake this way has been one of the greatest holiday gifts I could have given myself—and an effective hosting tranquilizer. I’ve given recipes and directions, including alternatives and options, for 9 of my favorite make-ahead cakes. This group is especially suited to the winter holidays. I know, once you’ve given the method a try, you’ll find other recipes to add to your list.
3) If you want to preserve some of these cakes for another occasion, positioning them on the table is important. It guides people away from cutting into them willy-nilly. I often cut a slice or two from the trunk of the log to give direction or a thin slice from the round cakes. The layered cakes can simply be sliced while frozen and the slices arranged on a plate for a new presentation. The log can usually be presented in its original form, but it too can be sliced to share the plate with the other cakes.
4) The fruit bread, tart and crisp are stored in the refrigerator not the freezer. Cut the remainder of the fruit “cakes” into interesting shapes or fingers, and present them plated with small squares of a quick muffin fruit mix, like Jiffy, baked in a loaf pan, with sugar and cinnamon sprinkled on top. It creates an economical, efficient and attractive presentation.
